Disclaimer: This is an opinion piece, I am by no means an expert and am just voicing my viewpoint on the subject.
I see it often, as news on Twitter and Facebook. “A game fully accessible for the blind!” and I go check it out, and it’s a game that’s just a completely black screen, with auditory feedback only. Perhaps some tactile feedback as well, but to me, those games don’t quite cut it. I won’t say it’s not accessible, because it is, but at the same time it feels like it’s still limiting the amount that the blind can play with their sighted peers. Before I get fully into this post though, I’d like to say I’m super happy with the headway accessibility has gotten in the past ten years. The fact that it’s something game developers are even thinking about, and implementing in their games is amazing, and makes me want to get back into gaming again. I saw that even big companies, like Microsoft and Sony are putting text to speech controls in their consoles, and I’m hoping that the Switch will follow suit (though the HD Rumble is a step in the right direction). Indi developers that think about how to adapt their games, and create games specifically for the blind isn’t something that I would see when I was a teenager and pre-teen, and it warms my heart to see that people are even thinking of how to make things easily available for everyone to play.
With that out of the way, I feel like making games without graphics isn’t exactly the right way to go with making games accessible. I know being legally blind is a rather blanket term, but being legally blind, or visually impaired, doesn’t always mean someone is 100 percent blind. There are people who have full sight out of one eye, have light perception, tunnel vision, peripheral vision, and so many other visual spectrums, that developers should account for. Sure, a legally blind gamer who has sight in one eye but none in the other may like to play a game that doesn’t have any visuals, but they also may not care for that sort of game and want to play something that has graphics they can see to the best of their ability, to immerse them further in the gaming experience also available to their sighted peers.
Blindness is a term a lot of us use because it’s easiest to say instead of something like “I’m actually visually impaired, I can see colors and light perception” because to a lot of people, that’s hard for them to grasp. I know I’ve seen a lot of blind gamers just say, give me good sound design in a Triple A title I’ll do the rest with my other senses. For some, being able to magnify things is enough, while for others, the text to speech menu options are all they’d need. Others would just need inverted color schemes, while others may prefer a fully audio, fully tactile game.
What I prefer in a game, is just to have the entire experience, like any normal game. Sound design is fantastic nowadays: I watch videos of games on YouTube, and can tell what’s going on just by the placement of the sound. I don’t have any new gen consoles, but I can only imagine how easy it is to play and how immersive it is for a blind gamer. I memorize where things are, or get sighted help from friends and family when something is too difficult, but overall that’s usually my gaming experience. That being said, I love fighting games for how easy they are to just pick up and play. Pick a mode, pick a fighter, and you’re good to go XD
Like I said, I’m super impressed, and happy to see the strides that developers, both big and small are taking towards gaming being doable for everyone. But when I see a game that says it’s fully accessible, but is lacking in features, I’m always so conflicted. I love that people are doing it, but at the same time, why not do it so it’s literally accessible to everyone? Games like 1, 2, Switch are doing a good job of being playable for everyone, while not looking like it’s excluding anyone from being able to play, and I think that’s more what developers need to stride for as far as making a game fully accessible goes. A no graphics, audio only game may be interesting, and a good game to have out there but at the end of the day it’s very niche and won’t be as interesting a game to play as say, a Final Fantasy game and I’d overall just like to see more access to games that are more mainstream. Good steps in the right direction on all fronts though, very interested to see where game development for the blind and visually impaired will be going in the next few years.
Have any thought’s on the subject? Would love to hear in the comments!